A CEO on the phone, not long ago: more than €100,000 spent on prospecting. Email campaigns, LinkedIn, setting, a salesperson hired and trained for a year. Zero clients signed. And the worst part: it wasn’t his fault. He never got to test before paying. This page gives you what you need to choose an outbound agency (or a lead generation agency, same question) with your eyes open: one rule, two traps, five questions and a test. You can apply it to any agency, ours included.
The market rewards the best sellers, not the best operators
“You’re all selling dreams.” That’s what this CEO told us. Hard to deny: selling is our job. An outbound agency is bound to be good at selling itself. It’s the core skill of the industry.
Direct consequence: an agency’s sales pitch tells you nothing about its ability to deliver. Slides, logos, volume promises: everyone has them. What separates agencies is what they’re willing to show and prove before you sign.
The rule: 3 to 4 months with no meetings means it’s the provider
Remember this rule: if you’ve paid an agency for 3 or 4 months and got zero meetings, your market isn’t the problem. The provider is.
We mean meetings, not clients. Sales cycles can be long, especially in high-ticket B2B. But conversations with people in your target can’t fail to happen. The biggest companies in the world prospect. Your business doesn’t have a market that’s “too complicated”. If three or four months go by without a single conversation, stop paying and ask why, in writing.
With us, the first meetings come in during month one (the time to set up infrastructure, offer and lists), and cruising speed starts in month two.
Two traps when choosing an outbound agency: single-channel and commission-only
Single-channel. Channels breathe. Email outperforms for two months, then LinkedIn, then the phone. An agency with only one method will squeeze every client into it, even when the channel doesn’t fit your target. Multichannel outbound (email, phone, LinkedIn) isn’t a luxury. It’s what lets you follow the channel that’s breathing.
Commission-only. It’s the reflex of someone who’s been burnt before, and we get it. Except an agency paid only on commission sends you everything, unqualified: 50 meetings, 40 of them dead. And the pressure flips: “your closing is the problem”.
Serious variable pay exists. But it makes sense for companies already equipped to absorb it: leaders in their market, with a real sales team, a high-ticket offer and volume behind it. For a company doing a few hundred thousand euros in revenue, a clear monthly retainer with a written definition of a qualified meeting protects you better. That’s our model, detailed on our pricing page. The pay-per-meeting trap has its own page: pay-per-meeting lead generation.
5 questions to ask an outbound agency before you sign
Question #1: “What’s a qualified meeting?” Get it in writing. If the definition doesn’t suit you, don’t sign. No refund promise is worth anything without it.
Question #2: “What happens if it’s off-target?” One right answer: they replace it. No debate.
Question #3: “Who handles no-shows?” The agency. Reminders, replacements, follow-up before the meeting: not you. You sell and you deliver.
Question #4: “Show me a real campaign.” The stats, the rates, the machine from the inside. If they stumble, you have your answer. For reference, we publish ours: 16 meetings in 8 days with 2 emails, numbers and email copy included.
Question #5: “Why these channels for my target?” If there’s no strategy before you sign, there won’t be one after. A good answer names your target, the channel that reaches it, and the offer that opens the conversation.
What to check in the contract itself is covered in lead generation agency contracts.
The test most agencies can’t take
If you remember one sentence:
“Prove it before I pay.”
A serious agency, with real callers and real infrastructure, can book you a qualified meeting for free. It costs them an hour or two of work. For you, it avoids betting thousands of euros a month on nice words, in a business where nice words are the core skill.
In our view, 95% of agencies can’t take this test. That’s exactly why we made it our offer: the first qualified meeting is free, before any commitment. Criteria written upfront, you judge the meeting, off-criteria we replace it. Not because we’re generous. Because we can. The full logic is in our risk reversal offer.
Before you sign your next contract
Three honest questions:
- Your last agency experience: did you have a written definition of a qualified meeting, or a verbal promise?
- Does your current provider show you campaigns, or slides?
- Before signing the next one: will you ask for proof, or pay again to find out?
And if you’re still torn between hiring and outsourcing, compare the cost of a salesperson trained for a year with a system already running: see SDR vs outbound agency and outsourced B2B outbound. Want to put us through the test? Book your call.
Every week, Célien takes apart a practice from his own industry in La Saturation, his newsletter (in French).