Case study · Cold email

16 meetings in 8 days, with 2 emails.

A cold email case study with every number on the table: the list, the 4-line email word for word, the follow-up, and the reflex that turns a reply into a booked meeting.

By Célien Botlan · October 2, 2026 · 4 min read

Everyone has an opinion on B2B cold email. It’s dead, it’s saturated, nobody reads it anymore. We’d rather run a campaign and publish the numbers. This cold email case study is our own: 2,778 companies contacted, 2 emails each, 16 qualified meetings booked in 8 days. You’ll see the list, the email word for word, the follow-up, and the exact moment a reply becomes a meeting.

The cold email case study results, number by number

The campaign offered one thing only: a free qualified meeting. Launched on a Monday, done in 8 days.

MetricResult
Companies contacted2,778
Emails sent5,400+
Open rate44.7%
Bounce rateunder 1%
Positive replies41
Qualified meetings booked16

The number that matters: one positive reply for every 132 emails. The market norm is around one in 400. Same channel, same tools as everyone else. The difference is somewhere else, and we’ll take it apart step by step.

You can watch the whole campaign on video, with the sending tool on screen, the real replies and a live call: the full video (in French).

The list: a broad target, every address verified

The list cost us almost no time. Agencies that sell to small and mid-sized businesses, pulled from a B2B database, with a broad target. We didn’t sweat personalization. We sweated the offer.

One step we never skip: verifying every address before sending. On one of our lists, a third of the addresses were risky or dead. Without verification, your inboxes get flagged and your campaign is dead before it starts. Here, under 1% bounce and clean deliverability from the first day to the last.

If you want the method to pull a clean list fast, it’s in how to build a B2B prospect list in 30 minutes.

The 4-line cold email, word for word

Subject line: “free meeting”. Lowercase. That’s it, and it got a 44.7% open rate.

The body (translated from French):

First name, what if we booked you a free meeting with a small business looking for exactly what you do at Company? We handle the list, the messages, the follow-ups. You just show up to the meeting. Worth me telling you more?

Plus a PS with proof: a meeting booked the week before for a web agency, with a CEO in advanced talks, and a client who had signed more than €7,350 of business from that free meeting.

Why it works. Four elements, not one more:

  • A precise, checkable promise: a meeting with a company looking for what you do.
  • Zero effort for the prospect: we handle the list, the messages, the follow-ups.
  • A closed CTA: one possible answer, yes or no.
  • Real proof in the PS.

No agency introduction, no list of services, no “let me introduce myself”. The email sells a first experience, not a contract. That’s the principle of a front-end offer, and it’s exactly our free first meeting.

The next-day follow-up that gives instead of begging

The follow-up goes out the next day. It doesn’t ask “did you see my email?”. It adds value:

I forgot the most important part: the meeting is qualified against your criteria, written down before we start. If it’s off-criteria, we replace it. I also have a 2-minute video showing how we generate it. Want me to send it?

Two things added: a safety net (written criteria, replacement) and a resource (the video). The follow-up removes the last reason to say no, instead of reminding the prospect you’re waiting.

Two emails in total. Not fifteen follow-ups, not a complicated funnel.

The reflex behind the 16 meetings: we pick up the phone

The decisive moment of the campaign isn’t in the email. It’s right after.

A positive reply means a phone call within minutes. Not an email back, not a calendar link. We find the number and we call. The prospect just read the email, the topic is still in their head, they place us in three seconds. Once they pick up, the booking almost always follows.

We sum it up like this: open cold, convert warm. Email raises hands, a human turns them into calendar slots. Why that delay matters so much is covered in buying signals in B2B outbound.

And the positive replies that didn’t book yet aren’t lost. They’re 41 warm leads to work over the following months. That’s the real capital of a campaign.

What you can reuse on your next campaign

Three questions before your next send:

  1. Does your first message fit in 4 lines, or 15? If you need 15 lines to explain your offer, the offer is what needs work.
  2. Your last positive reply: did you answer by email, or did you call? If you emailed, you let the only moment the prospect was warm go cold.
  3. Is your list verified before sending? If not, your deliverability is burning while you read this.

Stop overcomplicating cold email. An offer that gives, a short message, a clean list, and someone who picks up the phone when a hand goes up.

Want the same campaign built step by step for your market? The full launch sequence is in how to launch an outbound campaign.

Installing this machine for you (email infrastructure, offer, list, and the person who calls back) is what we do: it’s our cold email agency work and our B2B appointment setting. The first qualified meeting is on us: book your call.

Every week, Célien breaks down a real campaign or acquisition machine in his newsletter, La Saturation (in French).

FAQ

What is a good positive reply rate for B2B cold email?

On this campaign we got one positive reply for every 132 emails sent. The market norm sits around one positive reply per 400 emails. The gap didn't come from the tool or the list. It came from the offer.

How many emails should a cold email sequence have?

Here, two: a 4-line first email and a follow-up the next day. Past three follow-ups, you burn your name. Better to archive the contact and come back later, or when a real signal shows up.

Do you need to personalize every cold email?

Not on this campaign. The target was broad and the email was identical for everyone, apart from first name and company name. The time went into the offer, not into personalization.

What should you do when a prospect replies positively to a cold email?

Call them within minutes. Don't answer by email and don't send a calendar link. Once they pick up, the booking almost always follows. Every hour you wait cools down interest you paid to create.

Last step

We book your first meeting. You judge it.

A 30-minute video call, in French or English. We write your criteria together and you leave with your company's acquisition plan. The first meeting is on us.

Prefer to write? WhatsApp ↗